Only 10% of SOCs Say They're Getting Excellent Value From AI. Here's What the Second Wave Has to Deliver
Only about 10% of SOCs report receiving excellent value from their AI deployments, according to the SOC-CMM 2026 Maturity Report. The report surveyed roughly 200 SOCs and found that 71% saw only some value or none at all — a structural gap driven by off-the-shelf AI deployed without customization. The solution is an architectural shift from point AI tools to agentic SOC platforms that operate across the full security lifecycle.

Eighteen months ago, the AI-powered security operations center was a marketing line. Today, it is a budget line item. The AI SOC category has crossed over from interesting to inevitable, with billions of dollars flowing into AI security operations platforms, agentic SOC tools, and AI co-pilots built into every layer of the security stack. The data shows SOCs are buying, deploying, and standing up AI capabilities at the fastest pace the industry has ever seen.
And yet, the same SOCs reporting record AI adoption are also reporting underwhelming outcomes. The first objective benchmark on the value of AI in the SOC was published in the SOC-CMM 2026 Maturity Report in May, drawing on survey data from roughly 200 SOCs across regions, sectors, and delivery models. The findings paint a troubling picture: only about 10% of respondents said AI has delivered excellent value to their SOC. About 19% reported good value. The remaining 71% landed at some value or none at all.
Three Key Findings From the SOC-CMM 2026 Report
Three findings in the report stand out, and they correlate cleanly with each other when read together.
1. AI Adoption Is Up Across Every Category
Off-the-shelf large language models grew 55% year over year. AI co-pilots grew 145%. AI agents grew 118%. Supervised machine learning grew 96%. Customized LLMs grew 64%. SOC teams are over-investing in AI without the operational maturity to extract value from what they bought.
2. The "Taker" Model Dominates
The dominant adoption pattern is what the report calls the taker model: off-the-shelf AI deployed inside an existing security stack without customization. About 65% of SOCs surveyed describe themselves as takers. Another 20% are shapers, customizing what they buy. Only 15% are builders, training models against their own data. The takers are the largest cohort and the cohort reporting the least value. The pattern cuts across delivery model, region, and sector — the cause is structural, not superficial.
3. The Maturity Gap Widens
The report flags that the two SOC improvement challenges that grew year over year are lack of best practices (+17%) and complexity of increasing maturity (+11%). Every other challenge category, including lack of budget and lack of management support, dropped. SOCs are not saying they lack money or executive support. They are saying they do not know what they are supposed to be doing with the AI they bought.
The First Wave: AI Per Stage, Not Across Stages
The first wave of AI SOC tools shipped as features bolted onto existing security products. SIEMs got AI triage. EDRs got AI investigation. SOAR platforms got AI playbook generation. Ticketing tools got AI summarization. Each feature was real and worked in isolation. None of them shared context with the next.
In practice, this means SOC analysts now have five AI assistants instead of one. The triage agent in the SIEM does not know what the detection engineer silenced last week. The threat hunting agent in the EDR does not know what the threat intel team flagged that morning. The summarization agent in the ticketing tool does not know what the investigation surfaced two hops ago. Each agent accelerates its own slice of the workflow. None of them fixes the handoffs between slices — which is where most SOC time and value live.
The SOC-CMM 2026 report puts numbers on this. The technology domain scores an average of 2.7 out of 5 in maturity. The process domain, where the handoffs between SOC stages live, scores 2.3. The people domain scores 2.3 as well. Buying more tools — including AI ones — does not move those numbers. In some SOCs it makes them worse, because each new tool adds a handoff.
What Separates the 10%: Architectural Change
The 10% of SOCs reporting excellent value from AI are not running different point tools. They are running AI inside a different architectural structure. Three things separate them from the 71%:
- Unified lifecycle coverage: AI agents that operate across the full SOC lifecycle — from threat intelligence and threat hunting through detection engineering, investigation, and remediation — instead of inside a single stage.
- Institutional knowledge persistence: AI systems that continuously ingest the organization's assets, analyst judgment, sanctioned actions, escalation criteria, and historical incident outcomes.
- Defensible governance: Every agent action carries a reasoning chain and evidence trail, with customer-set scope and authority that expands as confidence builds.
The fix is connecting the stages. More AI inside the same fragmented architecture compounds the original problem. That connective fabric is what "second wave" means: the first wave delivered AI per stage; the second wave delivers AI across stages.
The Path Forward: From "Some Value" to "Excellent Value"
Adversaries are not waiting for the second wave to arrive. Google's Threat Intelligence Group disclosed the first confirmed AI-developed zero-day exploit earlier this year. Anthropic's Claude Mythos preview is identifying critical vulnerabilities at machine speed. JPMorgan's CISO published an open letter warning that the economics of cyber risk are shifting and that security buyers need to demand secure-by-default products.
The 10% number in the SOC-CMM 2026 report is a signal about the architecture most SOCs run right now. It is also a signal about which side of the next breach narrative each SOC will be standing on. The vendors and platforms that deliver AI across the full SOC lifecycle — not just inside individual tools — are the ones whose customers will move from "some value" to "excellent value" in next year's benchmark.


